Navigating the Transition: The Challenge of Moving from Ponies to Horses for Young Adult Riders

Young Adult Riders: The Growing Gap in Horse Showing

A hot topic stirring up the horse industry is based on the observation that young adult riders often struggle when transitioning from ponies to horses in the show ring. This phenomenon, which has mystified many for years, seems uniquely connected to equestrian sports. Just imagine: 19-year-old Michael Pender took the renowned Hickstead Derby on a horse, not a pony. Why then do junior riders face such hurdles when they switch to horses?

Exploring The Issue

To begin unpacking this subject, it's worth noting that the British Show Pony Society (BSPS) has introduced experimental intermediate horse classes. These cater specifically to hack and riding horse types and their riders who are below 25. This is certainly an innovative move. As it currently stands, the intermediate show riding type class has meandered from its initial intention over time. What was once meant to be a class for young adults riding horses, now often showcases a 148cm show pony masquerading as a hack. Such skewing has led to confusion regarding animal type, and the class seems to require a return to its roots.

Understanding the Peter Pan Effect

Only a minimal number of these younger jockeys participate in both adult and intermediate classes. Such low crossover raises the question of whether the current class format successfully transitions these riders into adult contenders. Are we possibly feeding the Peter Pan effect, where riders, like the boy who never grew up, are becoming stuck at an intermediate level? The class's aim should be certain: to prepare and transition BSPS riders positively into the adult ranks. To achieve such, the focus should lie on the type, way of going, appropriate conduct, and turnout.

Outgrowing Ponies: A Natural Progression

One frequent query among parents is, "What can my child do with their outgrown pony?" In most cases, it's time to move on. A pony simply won't fit the criteria for horse classes. Maybe the BSPS could consider adding more performance-style contests open to all ages, although the importance of the rider being mounted suitably can't be overlooked. As children grow, outgrowing ponies is inevitable. I personally loved my jumping ponies as a child, but when the time came, I enthusiastically transitioned to horses.

Questioning the Current Approach

Are we perhaps too protective of these young adults today? For comparison, consider that at age 18, one can legally consume alcohol, and by 21 can operate an HGV. Internationally, young people have demonstrated fantastic achievements in athletics. Luke Littler was runner-up in the world darts championships against adults at just 16, and Mike Tyson claimed the World Boxing Council heavyweight championship at a mere 20 years old. Given these accomplishments, it stands to reason that young adults should have the skills and confidence to ride and prepare a horse for show. Should there be a change in the format of intermediate classes? We believe it's high time we start this conversation. We must prepare the horse and young rider for the classes they aim to progress to in the future. Let's make it happen! Source: Simon Reynolds: ‘Is showing too protective of its young adults?’ - Horse & Hound, 23 March, 2024.